| Feature | Systematic Desensitisation | Flooding |
|---|---|---|
| Pace | Gradual and stage-based | Sudden and immediate |
| Patient Control | High; patient determines progression | Low; exposure is intense and sustained |
| Mechanism | Counter-conditioning (Relaxation) | Extinction (Exhaustion of fear) |
| Duration | Multiple sessions over weeks/months | One or two long sessions (2-3 hours) |
Research Support: Clinical studies consistently show that SD is effective in reducing fear levels over both short-term and long-term periods (e.g., follow-ups after several months).
Patient Suitability: Because it is gradual and less traumatic than other behavioral therapies, it is often more suitable for children or individuals with learning disabilities who may struggle with high-intensity treatments.
Symptom Substitution: A common criticism from psychodynamic perspectives is that SD treats the behavioral symptom rather than the underlying cause, potentially leading to the emergence of new phobias.
Identify the Mechanism: When describing SD, always mention reciprocal inhibition and counter-conditioning to demonstrate a deep understanding of the behavioral theory.
The Three Pillars: Ensure your answer covers all three components: the hierarchy, relaxation training, and the exposure process. Omitting relaxation often results in significant mark loss.
Evaluation Balance: When evaluating, contrast SD's high completion rates (due to its low-stress nature) with its potential lack of external validity if the patient cannot transfer skills to real-world settings without a therapist.