| Feature | Qualitative Forecasting | Quantitative Forecasting |
|---|---|---|
| Data Basis | Subjective judgment and intuition | Objective historical data and statistics |
| Best Use Case | New products or changing markets | Established products with stable history |
| Cost/Time | Often high due to expert involvement | Low once the model is established |
| Accuracy | Better for long-term strategic shifts | Better for short-term operational precision |
Simple vs. Weighted Moving Average: A simple moving average treats all historical periods equally, while a weighted moving average assigns specific importance (weights) to certain periods, usually favoring the most recent data to capture current trends.
Seasonality vs. Cyclicality: Seasonality occurs within a fixed period (e.g., monthly or quarterly), whereas cyclicality refers to long-term economic cycles (e.g., recessions) that do not have a fixed duration.
Check the Smoothing Constant: In exponential smoothing problems, remember that a high (close to 1) makes the forecast highly responsive to recent changes, while a low (close to 0) produces a very stable, slow-moving forecast.
Verify the Lag: When using moving averages in a trending market, the forecast will always 'lag' behind the actual data. If sales are rising, the moving average will consistently underestimate the next period.
Error Calculation: Always use absolute values when calculating Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD). If you don't use absolute values, positive and negative errors will cancel each other out, giving a false impression of perfect accuracy.
Sanity Check: After calculating a forecast, ask if the number makes sense given the trend. If your calculated forecast is lower than the last three periods of a clearly rising trend, you likely made a calculation error.
Over-fitting the Model: A common mistake is creating a complex model that perfectly matches historical noise but fails to predict future reality. Simpler models often perform better in volatile environments.
Ignoring External Shocks: Relying solely on internal historical data can be dangerous. A forecast that ignores a new competitor entering the market or a sudden change in regulation will likely be highly inaccurate.
Confusing Correlation with Causation: Just because two variables move together (e.g., ice cream sales and shark attacks) does not mean one causes the other. Regression models must be built on logical, causal relationships.