Removal of Prerogative Power: Prior to 2011, the Prime Minister could ask the Monarch to dissolve Parliament at any time, allowing them to time elections for maximum political advantage. The Fixed-term Parliaments Act (FTPA) removed this power, establishing a default five-year cycle for general elections.
Statutory Triggers for Early Elections: Under the FTPA, an early election could only be triggered by two specific mechanisms. The first is a motion for an early general election passed by at least of the total membership of the House of Commons.
Vote of No Confidence: The second trigger occurs if the House of Commons passes a motion of no confidence in the government. If no alternative government can be formed and win a vote of confidence within 14 days, a general election is automatically triggered.
Impact on Stability: This reform was crucial for the Coalition's survival, as it provided a legal guarantee that the junior partner (Liberal Democrats) would not be blindsided by a snap election called by the Prime Minister.
Scotland Act 2012: Following the Calman Commission, this Act granted the Scottish Parliament significant new powers, including the ability to set a Scottish rate of income tax and borrowing powers. This represented a shift toward 'fiscal federalism' within the UK.
Welsh Devolution: A 2011 referendum in Wales led to the granting of direct law-making powers to the Welsh Assembly (now Senedd) in 20 devolved areas, removing the need to consult Westminster for every piece of legislation.
Police and Crime Commissioners (PCCs): In an effort to decentralize power, the government introduced directly elected PCCs in 2012. These officials replaced appointed police authorities, aiming to make local policing more responsive to the public.
| Feature | Pre-2010 System | Coalition Reform (2010-2015) |
|---|---|---|
| Election Timing | Controlled by the Prime Minister via Royal Prerogative. | Controlled by Parliament via the Fixed-term Parliaments Act. |
| MP Accountability | MPs could only be removed at a General Election. | MPs can be 'recalled' by constituents for specific misconduct. |
| EU Power Transfer | Parliament could transfer powers to the EU via simple legislation. | The 'Referendum Lock' (2011 Act) required a public vote for any power transfer. |
| Welsh Authority | Required Westminster approval for specific laws (LCOs). | Direct law-making powers in devolved areas. |
Analyze the 'Why': When discussing the FTPA, always link it to the political necessity of coalition stability. It wasn't just a principled reform; it was a functional tool to keep two rival parties together.
Distinguish Outcomes: Be careful to distinguish between proposed reforms and actual changes. For example, the AV referendum and House of Lords reform are often cited as 'failures' or 'limitations' of the Coalition's constitutional agenda.
Evaluate Executive Power: A common exam question asks if the Coalition successfully reduced executive power. Use the FTPA as evidence for reduction, but contrast it with the government's ability to still dominate the legislative agenda through its majority.