| Feature | Simple Diffusion | Facilitated Diffusion | Active Transport |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protein Required | No | Yes | Yes |
| Energy (ATP) | No | No | Yes |
| Direction | Down gradient | Down gradient | Against gradient |
| Specificity | Low | High | High |
Identify the Gradient: Always check if the substance is moving from high to low concentration. If it is, and a protein is involved, it must be facilitated diffusion, not active transport.
Look for Specificity: If a question mentions a specific protein like an 'aquaporin' or 'ion channel,' the mechanism is facilitated diffusion.
Energy Check: Remember that the presence of a protein does NOT automatically mean energy is used. Facilitated diffusion is powered by the gradient itself, not ATP.
Saturation Curves: On a graph of transport rate vs. concentration, facilitated diffusion will level off (plateau) when proteins are saturated, whereas simple diffusion continues to increase linearly.
The 'Protein = Active' Error: Many students assume that because a protein is 'working' or changing shape, it must require ATP. In carrier proteins, the shape change is triggered by the binding of the solute, not by energy input.
Water Transport: While water can move via simple diffusion, the majority of rapid water movement in cells occurs via facilitated diffusion through aquaporins.
Gated Channels: Some students forget that channel proteins can be 'gated,' meaning they only open in response to specific electrical or chemical signals, but the movement remains passive.