It is vital to distinguish between the behavior of chromosomes in Meiosis I versus Meiosis II and Mitosis.
| Feature | Mitosis | Meiosis I | Meiosis II |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pairing of Homologues | No | Yes (Synapsis) | No |
| Crossing Over | No | Yes | No |
| What Separates? | Sister Chromatids | Homologous Pairs | Sister Chromatids |
| Outcome | 2 Identical Diploid | 2 Unique Haploid | 4 Unique Haploid |
In Meiosis I, the cell transitions from diploid to haploid because the homologous pairs are separated. In Meiosis II, the cell remains haploid, but the amount of DNA per cell is halved as sister chromatids separate.
The Centromere Rule: Always count chromosomes by the number of centromeres. Even if a chromosome consists of two sister chromatids, it is still considered ONE chromosome until the centromere splits.
Identify the Phase: If you see chromosomes lined up in pairs (double file), it is Metaphase I. If they are in a single file in a haploid cell, it is Metaphase II. If they are in a single file in a diploid cell, it is Mitosis.
Nondisjunction Analysis: If an error occurs in Meiosis I, all four gametes will be abnormal ( or ). If it occurs in Meiosis II, only two gametes will be abnormal, while two will be normal ().
DNA Content vs. Chromosome Number: Be careful with questions asking about DNA mass. DNA doubles during S-phase, is halved in Meiosis I, and halved again in Meiosis II, whereas chromosome number only drops during Meiosis I.
Interphase II Myth: A common mistake is assuming DNA replicates again between Meiosis I and Meiosis II. There is no second S-phase; the chromosomes entering Meiosis II are already replicated.
Sister vs. Non-sister: Crossing over occurs between non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes. Crossing over between sister chromatids would result in no genetic change because they are identical.
Haploid Definition: Students often think 'haploid' means the chromosomes are not replicated. A cell is haploid as soon as it lacks its homologous partner, regardless of whether the remaining chromosomes consist of one or two chromatids.