In a tube closed at one end, a displacement node (zero vibration) always forms at the closed end (water surface), while a displacement antinode (maximum vibration) forms near the open end.
The first resonance occurs when the length of the air column is approximately one-quarter of the wavelength: , where is the end correction.
The second resonance occurs when the length is approximately three-quarters of the wavelength: .
By subtracting the two lengths, the end correction is eliminated: , leading to the formula .
Setup: Partially submerge a long tube into a container of water to create a closed-end air column of adjustable length.
Excitation: Strike a tuning fork of known frequency with a rubber hammer and hold it horizontally just above the open end of the tube.
Finding Resonance: Slowly raise the tube out of the water. The first point where the sound volume reaches a maximum is recorded as .
Second Point: Continue raising the tube until the next volume maximum is found and record this length as .
Calculation: Use the relationship and substitute to find the speed of sound:
| Feature | First Resonance () | Second Resonance () |
|---|---|---|
| Wave Pattern | Quarter wavelength () | Three-quarters wavelength () |
| Nodes/Antinodes | 1 Node, 1 Antinode | 2 Nodes, 2 Antinodes |
| Length | Shortest resonant length | Approximately |
| Purpose | Establishes baseline | Used with to eliminate end correction |
Unit Consistency: Always ensure lengths and are converted from centimeters to meters before calculating the final speed in .
Temperature Awareness: The speed of sound is highly dependent on air temperature (). If an exam question provides the temperature, check if you need to compare your experimental result to the theoretical value at that temperature.
Identifying Resonance: In practical descriptions, emphasize that the 'loudest' sound indicates resonance. If the sound is faint, the tuning fork may need to be re-struck or held closer to the tube opening.
Reasonableness Check: The speed of sound in air at room temperature is approximately . If your calculated value is significantly different (e.g., or ), check for power-of-ten errors or missing factors of 2.
Forgetting the Factor of 2: A common error is using instead of . Remember that the distance between two consecutive nodes or antinodes is half a wavelength.
Tuning Fork Contact: Never let the vibrating tuning fork touch the rim of the tube; this creates mechanical vibrations that mask the acoustic resonance and can damage the equipment.
Parallax Error: When measuring the water level against a scale, the eye must be level with the meniscus to avoid reading the length incorrectly.
Misidentifying Harmonics: Students sometimes assume the second resonance is the 'second harmonic'. In a closed pipe, only odd harmonics exist, so the second resonance is actually the third harmonic ().