| Feature | Feminist View | Functionalist View |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of Institution | Conflict-based and patriarchal | Consensus-based and positive |
| Domestic Roles | Exploitative (Unpaid work) | Complementary (Instrumental/Expressive) |
| Impact on Society | Reinforces gender inequality | Maintains social stability |
| View of the Nuclear Family | Source of female oppression | The 'cornerstone' of society |
Identify Key Thinkers: Always mention Delphy and Leonard when discussing radical feminism or the patriarchal nature of the family. Link Ann Oakley to the concept of unpaid domestic work.
Use Contemporary Examples: When asked to evaluate, bring up the 'dual burden' or 'triple shift' (adding emotional labour) to show how traditional patterns persist despite modern workplace changes.
The 'Dark Side': Use evidence of domestic violence or child abuse to challenge the functionalist 'warm bath' theory, showing that the family is not a safe haven for everyone.
Check the Balance: In high-mark questions, balance the feminist critique with postmodern views that celebrate family diversity, noting that not all modern families follow the patriarchal nuclear model.
Ignoring Change: A common mistake is assuming feminists think all families are currently identical. In reality, they focus on structural trends while acknowledging that some families are more egalitarian than others.
Marxism vs. Feminism: Do not confuse the two. While Marxists focus on capitalism exploiting the family, feminists focus on patriarchy and how men specifically benefit from the arrangement.
Idealisation: Avoid the 'idealisation' pitfall of functionalism; remember to address the reality of 'dysfunctional' families where neglect or control is present.
Postmodernism: This perspective challenges feminism by arguing that individuals now have more choice and that family forms (lone-parent, reconstituted) are increasingly diverse and less bound by patriarchal tradition.
The Symmetrical Family: Sociologists like Willmott and Young argue that families are becoming more equal, a view that feminists often reject by pointing to the persistent 'dual burden' of domestic work.