The physical properties of allotropes are determined entirely by their internal bonding geometry and the availability of free charge carriers.
In diamond, all four outer-shell electrons of carbon are involved in localized covalent bonds, meaning there are no free-moving particles to carry an electric current.
In graphite, each carbon atom uses only three electrons for bonding within a layer, leaving one delocalized electron per atom that is free to move across the entire layer.
Covalent bonds require significant energy to break, leading to very high melting points (above C) for both diamond and graphite.
| Feature | Diamond | Graphite |
|---|---|---|
| Bonding | 4 bonds per Carbon | 3 bonds per Carbon |
| Geometry | 3D Tetrahedral | 2D Hexagonal Layers |
| Hardness | Extremely Hard | Soft and Slippery |
| Conductivity | Insulator | Electrical Conductor |
| Visual | Transparent/Clear | Opaque/Black |
The 'Why' Factor: Never just state a property; you must link it to the structure. For example, do not just say 'Graphite is soft.' Say 'Graphite is soft because the layers are held by weak intermolecular forces and can slide over each other.'
Conductivity Keywords: When explaining graphite's conductivity, you MUST use the term delocalized electrons. Ensure you mention they are free to move throughout the structure.
Melting Point Reasoning: For both diamond and graphite, explain high melting points by stating that 'many strong covalent bonds must be broken, which requires a large amount of energy.'
Common Mistake: Do not confuse 'intermolecular forces' in graphite with the bonds within the layers. Covalent bonds within graphite layers are incredibly strong; only the forces between the layers are weak.
The Graphite Paradox: Students often think graphite must have a low melting point because it is soft. This is false; melting involves breaking the strong covalent bonds within the layers, not just separating the layers.
Valency Confusion: Remember that carbon always has 4 valence electrons. In graphite, the 'missing' 4th bond is represented by the delocalized electron, not by a change in carbon's fundamental chemistry.
Molecular vs. Giant: Neither diamond nor graphite are 'simple molecular' substances. Avoid using the word 'molecule' when describing them; use 'giant lattice' or 'macromolecule' instead.
Graphene: A single layer of graphite. It is essentially a 2D material with incredible strength and high electrical conductivity, currently a major focus of nanotechnology.
Fullerenes: Carbon allotropes formed into hollow spheres (like ) or tubes. These have different properties again, showing the versatility of carbon bonding.
Industrial Applications: Diamond's hardness makes it ideal for industrial drill bits and glass cutters, while graphite's properties make it the primary component in pencil 'lead' and high-temperature lubricants.